Sunday, December 14, 2008

The .303 Problem.

.303 is the name of the work horse of Indian Police services. It's a rifle that has been in service since the British Raj. If you are too particular about the dates, then 1880 it was , when the Rifle actually shipped out of it's factories. So for the last 128 years, the .303 Rifle has been untiringly rendering it's service in almost all the police forces in our country (State police forces) without exception. The paramilitary forces too used it as it's primary weapon till as late as 2001 when finally it's was firmly phased out in favour of the SLR (Self Loading Rifle, a 1950's product) during the tenure of Home secretary Kamal Pandey. But it's not as bad as it all sounds cos even though it's old, it's a very effective weapon with a fair degree of stopping power. And better, most of our policemen are actually trained on the .303 , so that ends up making it one of the most effective weapons in their hands when an 'aimed firing' need arises. The .303 did even prove it's mettle in the Parliament attacks in 2001.

But times & circumstances have changed a lot since 2001. And the present era calls for a huge spending towards modernisation of our Police forces. And of course, a systematic de-coupling of the police-politician nexus.

We as a nation have some of the best elite forces in the whole world , as proved in Mumbai. They are amongst the most intensively trained for sure. But as Mumbai again proved, the first line of defence in our system is always invariably the state police forces. And we saw heartening scenes when the brave Mumbai police jawans devoid of bullet proof jackets took on the terrorists with their .303's. It also proved systemic failures when the elite forces took more than acceptable time to reach the scene of crime. Also , we shouldn't forget that the most adopted terror tactic against our nation has been bombs dropped in trash cans, Mumbai was a new form which might not repeat itself again.

India today pays Trillions of rupees in taxes every year.We definitely have money to upgrade out on security. The political will hopefully will come now. As for upgradation of the .303, the most common excuse given is that an Automatic weapon in the hands of a routine beat policeman is too dangerous, for the unfortunate event of him becoming hostile, the risk would run high. It's a classic example of not attacking the root cause of the problem.

The average police constable doesn't live too comfortable a life if he belongs to the non 'Chai-pani' cadre. Having personally seen the lifestyle of the lowest rung of our forces, I am not usually surprised when I hear stories of Indian policemen going hostile against their own comrades. The problems are almost the same as the other low income Indian families. Daily family issues, Childrens quality education, daughters wedding, supporting parents back home etc.. Now add to that 12 hour work shifts, routine denial of eligible leave , no tolerance for revolt, punishment codes and strict disciplinary actions.

The mordernisation of out State police forces have to start from the bottom. Govt housing has to be ensured for all, creation of Police schools on the lines of Army schools, subsidized ration/groceries, counselling services,strict 8 hour workshifts, subsidized personal loans etc.. might be a good idea to start with. The point being , a constable who is adequately rested with lot less worries back home would be infinetely more effective than someone who is refused to go home to attend his sister's marriage and yes, lot less dangerous when he is armed while on duty. It is when we meet & solve this fundamental issues with our police forces that we can actually go and mordernise the .303's with AK 47's and Mp5 machine guns without any fear. Another important aspect is the working condition. Police stations should be equipped with technology. Special vehicles should be custom made for Chase operations. And all policemen on duty should be available on the radio.

One might ask, how in the world would these things help when most of the police force in our country is inherently corrupt. My answer is simple - No human being is bad by birth. It's circumstances that exist in our society today that makes us bad/corrupt/unethical. Lets change the fundamentals, we have got them wrong. And let's see if that brings about an attitudinal shift in the system. That's the best hope we can have today.It also comes from close observation of the system. An armed policemen is almost often never seen accepting bribes. I feel it's due to mere sense of ownership that comes automatically when a task demanding some responsibility is assgined to you. So when we create an ecosystem wherein we have a lot less stressed policemen on the street, armed, on the radio recieving intelligence, with a happy family back home, a financially sound bank account, a well equipped work place to head back to, I personally feel we would have created a very strong first line of defence. And that might make all the difference in most of the cases.

9 comments:

opal said...

I completely agree with You.Lets not forget the traffic policemen who spent most of their shift under burning sun, having to suffer traffic pollution and worst of all abusive languages being showered on them by the drivers in case of a block.They deserve much better treatment.

sukumar said...

Good one Ranjit. When we can spend valuable taxpayer money on giving free TVs worth 7500 crores and counting, we can definitely upgrade our security forces weaponry.

Sriram said...

The darndest thing is that these rifles would have been enough! The policeman at the station was woefully outa practice and hence had not practice shooting his rifle. He did not fire his weapon at the terrorists and another policeman had to grab his rifle and shoot. And the rifle jammed after firing two rounds!

Just by increasing the training of the policeman in using their firearms periodically would have negated the above two. Imagine, if the terrorists had been gunned down in the station itself.

ranjit nair said...

You are right Opal.
Stricter laws and enforcement should reduce the stress on Trafic policemen. Somehow in India we think that driving in any fashion is our democratic right. Once hefty fines & compulsary jail terms/on spot 10k fine for drunken driving etc..is imposed , only then we would mend our ways.

And yes, when that is fixed, we can add more automated signals with the hope that we all follow it systematically. Signals and discipline can reduce interventions needed by policemen.

ranjit nair said...

Thanks for sharing Sukumar.
Yes, & I feel we can learn 2 cents from the point Obama made recently. Govts shouldn't keep throwing money at a problem thinking that they would get fixed. Strict & effective monitoring of the funds till the last penny should be enforced.

And yes, in case of our country, we first need to even look at where the money is headed as you pointed out.

ranjit nair said...

Agree with you Sriram. As I said, for aimed firing, .303 would have been enough.
But I won't be the best person to say why the policeman didn't fire. He might have been numbed by the severity of the event or something else, we can't comment. What I do know is that it's very difficult by Indian laws for a police constable to raise his rifle and kill another human being. Our laws are so strict that even a mad elephant on the rampage killing people cannot be shot at unless ordered by the District Collector.

So I guess a systemic solution has to be found out. Then again, policemen could be very well out of practice too. Though I believe firing practices once every 6 months is mandatory in all armed forces in India, won't be surprised if lot of people are let off without undergoing it..Remember , it's our India, the 'Chaltha hain' attitude. Not any more, I hope.

Sara said...

Very true Ranjit, the funds that fill the potbellies should be put to use,now!!

psenthilraja said...

I agree with your point, that we need to provide better amenities to the lowermost rank of the police constables..

in my opinion, a policemen should not be valued on just money.. he has to be valued on the protection he provides..

There should be atleast basic set of amenities for pollice constable, so that he need not worry for his family of children..

Also money should not be the benchmark for everything.. if the government decides to provide the police force with amenities, it can be in lot of ways apart from being monetory..
Like providing free health care, free education to the children etc.

ranjit nair said...

You are right on the point senthil. More than money,it's the fulfilment of other needs like quality housing,sound education & a relaxed family life that motivates one to deliver better.